Skip to Main Content

Discovery Services Procedures: Duplicates Project

"How to" documents for OCLC, Alma, and general Discovery Services Procedures.

Duplicates Project - Discovery Services Procedures

Discovery Services Procedures

All Discovery Services students will participate in pulling books from the Main stacks for this project.

Students who need Library of Congress Classification call number training, should review this handout and use this exercise. Both of these are located in the Discovery Services Procedures research guide in the Student Training tab.

Students should work on this project when they are not working on their regular duties or higher priority projects. This project is a medium priority project.

    • Regular duties include: mail delivery, answering the dock door (when alone), processing new orders/books, processing large donations/damages, weeding, processing new shipments, physical processing, microfilm preservation, and index projects.
    • Higher priority projects: N/A at this time

Project Steps

  • The flow of lists of books to be pulled may not always be constant, so staff must remain flexible.
  • Students should report if books are out of order on the shelves and send pictures to Joy of those sections.
  • Students will be provided a list of books to pull from Joy, Virginia, or an intern when available.
  • Students should pull books as long as they are available but should take a break if longer than two hours.
  • Students are to pull books only if they located both copies of the same title and same call number.
    • If they are unsure or if they cannot determine which copy is in worse condition, students should bring all copies down.
    • Worse condition: Joy, Virginia, or an intern will determine which book is in the best condition to be returned to Access Services.
      • This copy should be returned to Access Services immediately to be reshelved.
      • Students should report that the book had not been used or picked up so that Access Services does not enter a pick-up count.
    • To determine the condition, Virginia has created instructions for the students. See Condition Selection tab.
  • Students need to mark what items were found and not found on their list. See the table of responses below.
  • Joy will have a student enter this information according to the online spreadsheet.
  • When students return with trucks of books, they will load the shelves in Metadata Services, so staff Oscar, Cynthia, Alejandra, and Robert can load their trucks or ask students if they have time to load their individual truck.
    • Overflow shelves will also be located in M&M as needed. M&M students may generally also leave theirs there for Robert's convenience.
    • Joy, Virginia, or an intern will coordinate with this staff to ensure each receives a steady amount.
  • Once staff processes the withdrawn books, they will deliver the books to Norma’s and/or Robert’s students for physical processing of withdrawing the materials. Alejandra’s student will also work on withdrawals as long as there is time.
  • Once the processing is complete, books should be recycled into bins in the back hallway.
    • If there is no room, please let Joy know.
    • If trucks need to be held back while trash is collected, trucks will need to be marked with a “WITHDRAWN” note.

This is still an evolving process. As new things come up, procedures can change. Please remain flexible and keep communication open. Changes are italicized.

Description / Issue Notes for Sheet Action
  • Different volumes, not copies
  • Different editions
  • Same titles, Different covers
  • Different sizes
ND or Not Dup = Not Duplicate Leave on shelf

Different call number (letter on end)

  • HB123.A34 1990 (1 copy)
  • HB123.A34 1990b (1 copy)
ND or Not Dup = Not Duplicate Leave on shelf

Different call number (letter on end)

  • HB123.A34 1990 (1 copy)
  • HB123.A34 1990b (2 copies)

HB123.A34 1990 - Not Duplicate

HB123.A34 1990b - Duplicate

Leave on shelf

Pull 1 copy

Only 1 copy on shelf 1 copy or 1x Leave on shelf
2 copies found check mark Pull one copy
3 copies or more found check mark Leave only 1 copy on shelf
Nothing found NF = Not Found Move on to the next one

NOTE: Only pay attention to highlighted notes on the printed spreadsheet.

Instructions for Selecting the Best Condition Copy

Objective: we need your help selecting between two copies of each book. The better copy will be kept in our collection, and the other will be withdrawn.

  1. Check the list
  • Locate both copies of the book in question
  • Examine the books
  1. Examine the covers:
  • Check both the front and back covers of each book
  • Look for any signs of tear, stains or fading
  • Note any significant damage (e.g. torn covers, missing cover)
  1. Inspect the spine
  • Examine the spine of the book
  • Check for any signs of damage break, or excessive bending
  • Ensure the titles on the spines are legible
  1. Assess the pages
  • Open the books and flip through the pages
  • Look for any tears, stains, markings, or signs of water damage
  • Pay attention to the binding and ensure pages are securely attached
  1. Check for annotations
  • Look for any writing, highlighting, or notes in the margins
  • Prefer the copy with fewer or no annotations
  1. Evaluate the Overall Conditions
  • Compare the overall appearance and condition of both copies
  • Consider the general cleanliness
  1. Make your decision:
  • Based on your evaluation, decide which copy is in better condition
  • The copy with fewer defects and in the best overall shape should be kept.

Note: Hardbound vs. paperbound books - if the hardbound is in good condition, keep the hardbound book over the paperbound book.

Note: if you encounter books that are difficult to evaluate or if both copies are in poor condition, please check with me.

V. Rassaei

500 W. University Avenue : El Paso, TX, 79968-0582 : (915) 747-5672
Copyright | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer
State Reports | UT System | Customer Service Statement | Site Feedback | Required Links |