Skip to main content

Dr. Potter's Library Guide: Is it a Scholarly, Peer-reviewed Article?

What are (Scholarly) Peer Reviewed publications?

Peer reviewed can mean:

  • Blind Peer Reviewed - (or Double Blind Peer Reviewed) - Articles appearing in a journal are sent outside of the journal's publishing or sponsoring organization for review by external reviewer(s), whereby the either author's identity or the reviewers' identity is unknown.

  • Editorial Board Peer Review - articles appearing in a journal are reviewed by an internal board of editors, not solely by one editor. The author's identity may be known or unknown.

  • Expert Peer Review - articles appearing in a journal are reviewed by experts (either internal or external to the journal) whose credentials are known and who are experts within the subject matter of the article under review. The author's identity may be known or unknown.

Source:

What are (scholarly) peer reviewed publications? (2014). [Web Page]. Retrieved from http://support.ebsco.com/knowledge_base/detail.php?id=976

Is it a Peer-reviewed Article?

Below is one process to tell whether the articles published in a particular journal have been through the peer-review process.

1. Find the About this journal section.

a. Type in journal title into the UTEP library online catalog’s E-Journals tab.

b. Click on Title Details.

c. Go to the publication’s Website.

d. Find the About section and read whether peer-reviewing is mentioned in the description.

2. Read the Bibliographic Information in the Library Record.  

a. Once you have found your journal title in the E-Journals tab, and clicked on title details, select Additional Title Details.

b. Look in Key Features.

In-class Exercise

Is it a Peer Reviewed Article?

 

A. Instructions: Which of these article citations comes from a peer-reviewed journal?

In MLA Style:

Bosworth, David. "From wariness to wishfulness: Disney's emasculation of Pinocchio's conscience." Georgia Review 65.3 (2011): 584-608. Web.

McGee, John. "Piloted by desire: The nautical theme in Romeo and Juliet." English Studies 95.4 (2014): 392-409. Web.

Zinoman, Jason. "Underneath the horror, evidence of some Heart." New York Times (2008): 8. Web.

In APA Style:

Bosworth, D. (2011). From wariness to wishfulness: Disney's emasculation of Pinocchio's conscience. The Georgia Review, (3). 584.

McGee, J. (2014). Piloted by desire: The nautical theme in Romeo and Juliet. English Studies, 95(4), 392-409.

Zinoman, J. (2008). Underneath the horror, evidence of some heart. The New York Times. p. C8.

 

Prove it! : 1) Provide the dates the peer-reviewed journal is available through the UTEP Library; 2) List the database(s) through which the peer-reviewed journal is available.

1)____________________________________________________________________________

2)___________________________________________________________________________

 

 

JOIN LINK: join.quizizz.com
GAME CODE: 807935

 

 

500 W. University Avenue : El Paso, TX, 79968-0582 : (915) 747-5672
Copyright | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer
State Reports | UT System | Customer Service Statement | Site Feedback | Required Links |